Category Archives: overrated

up in the air

slick, entertaining, and also appalling.

Posted in overrated | Leave a comment

Big Fan

I wasn’t. Robert Siegel’s film, a relentlessly-focused study of an obsessive Giants fan, has gotten a lot of love, for its nods to ‘seventies character studies (or at least its writer/director’s and star’s respective desire to emulate those studies) and … Continue reading

Posted in overrated | 4 Comments

Tell Everyone

to skip Tell No One, or at the very least ratchet down the hype and lower–no, more than lower: shove to the floor–your expectations. Imagine a more gallic Ron Howard taking a mediocre thriller, pumping it full of old r&b … Continue reading

Posted in overrated | 12 Comments

Slumdog Millionaire

Danny Boyle’s much ballyhooed film is a crowd pleasing tale of star crossed lovers searching for connection on the busy streets of Mumbai. Simplistic and sentimental, the dramatic action, which jumps back and forth in time throughout, cribs generously from … Continue reading

Posted in overrated | 23 Comments

Rachel Getting Married

HTM!!! Imagine Robert Redford’s Ordinary People–hopped up on steroids—colliding into a three-day “One World” music festival (you know: Peter Gabriel, Amadou and Mariam, Beausoleil, Damon Alburn, Jorge Ben, Clube Do Balanço, Manu Chao, Daft Punk, Toots and the Maytals, Bassekou … Continue reading

Posted in overrated | 15 Comments

persepolis

we can’t be the only ones who’ve seen this. it came highly recommended by our friends jane and karen in boulder, not to mention the majority of reliable film critics, but i fear i found it a little disappointing. which … Continue reading

Posted in likey, overrated, well, okay | 1 Comment

The Wind That Shakes the Barley

Caught Ken Loach’s latest, which won the 2006 Palm d’Or at Cannes, and was surprisingly disappointed (I like Loach’s work). It’s not that it’s a bad movie necessarily (it is, uncharacteristically, gorgeous to look at), but it is just so … Continue reading

Posted in (by verdict), overrated | 11 Comments

flag of our fathers

has anyone seen this? heart in the right place, i guess — heroes schmeroes, PTSD, the banal brutality of war. but why oh why do american directors have to spell everything out so damn explicitly? and why oh why do … Continue reading

Posted in overrated | 15 Comments

babel

schmabel

Posted in (by verdict), overrated | 11 Comments

films that don’t hold up

i remember liking lost in translation a lot when it first came out. i watched most of it again last night on ondemand and discovered that i didn’t really care for it at all, that all it is about really … Continue reading

Posted in (by verdict), overrated | 2 Comments